Who should be Manchester United's starting goalkeeper: Onana or Bayindir?

Manchester United face a difficult decision between their two goalkeepers, Andre Onana and Altay Bayindir, as they battle for the starting spot. Both keepers have brought unique qualities to the table, but inconsistencies in Onana's performances have opened the door for Bayindir to stake his claim.

Onana: The High-Risk, High-Reward Option

Signed from Inter Milan in the summer, Onana has undoubtedly brought a new dimension to Manchester United's play. His ability to play out from the back and start attacks has been a revelation. However, his occasionally erratic performances have raised questions about his consistency. Despite some impressive displays, Onana has also been culpable for high-profile errors that have cost his team points.

Bayindir: The Reliable Option

Altay Bayindir, on the other hand, has impressed with his consistency and reliability. The Turkish international has been a dependable presence between the sticks in the domestic cups and the Europa League. While he may not possess the same level of technical ability as Onana, Bayindir has shown himself to be a capable shot-stopper and has made several crucial saves.

The Case for Onana

• Playing style: Onana's ability to play out from the back is a valuable asset to the team, allowing them to build attacks from deep.
• Potential: The Cameroon international has the potential to become one of the best goalkeepers in the world.
• Experience: Onana has played at the highest level of club football and has the experience to handle the pressure of playing for a big club like Manchester United.

The Case for Bayindir

• Consistency: Bayindir has been more consistent than Onana, making fewer high-profile errors.
• Reliability: The Turkish goalkeeper has shown himself to be a reliable shot-stopper.
• Adaptability: Bayindir has quickly adapted to the demands of English football.

What does the future hold?

The decision of who to start in goal is a difficult one for manager Rúben Amorim. On one hand, Onana offers a higher risk, higher reward option, while Bayindir provides a more reliable and consistent performance. Ultimately, the decision will likely come down to which goalkeeper gives the team the best chance of winning.